This post is completely based on my personal opinion from my experiences with different computers, so you are more than welcome to disagree with me :P
People often ask me if I'm a Windows person or a Mac person. Honestly, I'm neither.
I'm not saying they're both bad operating systems. They both have their strong points and their weak points. It all depends on what you are looking for in a computer.
My preference for the last several years has been the Ubuntu distribution of Linux. I have played around with several and found that it suited my personal needs best.
"I'm not a computer nerd, why would I care about this Linux?!"
That's a good question! You have to ask yourself a few things...What do you use your computer for? What are the requirements you have during your day to day computing? What would be nice, but isn't necessary? What are you willing to give up to get a specific benefit?
So...What are some of the major differences between Windows, Mac, and Linux?
Windows. Who hasn't heard of it. Walk into any home or office and there is a very good chance their computers are running Windows. It's easy to use (when it's working...), it has a lot of support when you run into problems (and who doesn't?), and there is a vast number of programs available for it. It's installed on almost any computer you find in your local electronics store.
Windows is everywhere, "Everyone's doing it".
So if everyone is using it then it can't be all that bad can it? Besides the constant updates, viruses, blue screens of death, meaningless error messages, security pop ups, required system restarts, and on and on...so no, it's not all that bad...
Windows is good for the average user to get through their day. But what does the average user do when their Windows is broken? (pun intended). They can't do a whole lot by themselves. They have to try to figure it out, or pay someone like myself to fix the problem (with no real guarantee that it won't happen again). We can do things in an attempt to prevent problems from arising, like installing anti-virus software, running system cleaning software, or taking the computer in for regular maintenance. Regrettably there's nothing we can do to solve the main problem, the flaws in the operating system. It is full of holes that hackers take advantage of to get into your system, it easily accumulates start up software that slows your computer down, and much more.
Mac on the other hand is used by far fewer people. It is a more secure system and does not suffer from the same virus problems as Windows. However, it is NOT virus proof, it is just much harder to hack. Would you try to break into a small store with lots of security, or target the larger store next door with almost no security and a guard with a limp? Windows is so much easier to break into, and with 90% of people using it why wouldn't you target them? As more and more people move towards Mac computers so will the attention of hackers. They are also very good for editing music, video, and images. I have several friends in the film industry that love their Macs.
To me, one of the major downsides to a Mac is the lack of customization. Sure you can change some settings, but you don't have as much freedom. The added bonus to this is that the system is more stable because there is less for you to break.
I have come to strongly dislike the phrase "Mac just works"...I haven't had a lot of experience with Mac computers myself, but my first time using a Mac I ran into a software flaw that kept the email from functioning properly. I spent hours fighting with something that was just supposed to work. By following the newsletter from @RISK I have seen many more flaws pop up (Windows definitely has more, my point is that Mac is not "perfect", haha).
So how do you pick between them? Well, most people know how to use Windows, so moving to a Mac may be a difficult transition. Once you have figured out the new operating system then you may find you prefer it compared to Windows.
If you use your computer for business then you need to keep in mind what kind of software you use, is it Mac compatible (another option is using a virtual desktop, but I won't get into the details now)? If there is a Mac version, how much will it cost you to buy the new software and the new computer? Will the cost and trouble learning the new system be worth not having to deal with the flaws of Windows and viruses? Do you do a lot of online banking or keep confidential data on your computer?
If the computer is for personal use then what are your main needs? Do you browse the Internet? Use your email? Chat with friends and relatives? Listen to music? Maybe more, maybe less.
So...we have looked at Windows and Mac. Now what about Linux? Why would I want to talk about something obviously meant for computer savvy people on a blog that is not? Because it all depends on your needs.
I have set up more then one client with Ubuntu Linux on their computers. They did not require much of their computers, just things like browsing the Internet, checking email, printing, scanning, listening to music, word processing, etc. So far more than half of these clients have kept Ubuntu on their computers and the number of times they have had to call me with computer problems has drastically dropped (now it's usually just the odd call when they can't figure something out).
Linux doesn't suffer from viruses either (Mac computers actually use a version of Linux!) and doesn't collect startup software that slows the computer down. The majority of Linux software is free and open source as well, meaning that anyone can modify it if they want (so now we have a world of skilled programmers working to improve our software, instead of one company). But one of the main features about Linux that I personally love is the ability to customize everything. It's not always easy to change something, but the option is there, unlike in Windows and Mac. Also, Linux will run on any computer currently running Windows so you don't have to buy a whole new expensive machine.
So to summarize all of this, if you don't mind the risk of viruses, play a lot of higher end video games, use the computer in a work environment with Windows specific software, than Windows may be the best option for you. If you want a machine that doesn't have virus problems (yet), has a very 'pretty' interface, and costs a lot of money, then the Mac is a good option. Lastly, if you just want to be able to browse the internet, check your emails, listen to music, chat with friends, etc. and not have to worry about 'is this website safe?', or 'will this email kill my computer?', than maybe consider giving Linux a try.
If you are interested in trying Linux then I would suggest using a Live CD from the Ubuntu website. It allows you to run a fully functioning version of Linux without changing anything on the computer, so you can test it out before you ever actually install it. If you don't like it, just restart the computer, remove the CD, and you are back to your old Windows! (You may need to contact your computer manufacturer to figure out how to 'boot from the cd')
Brendan
- The Man Behind the Curtain